Makoto Ikeda / profile

Mr. Ikeda is a fan of Aarin(Ayaka Sasaki), a member of idol group Momoiro Clover Z.
He began to wear pink clothes, saying that pink, her official member color, pumps him up.
During one New Year’s holiday, he went to his wife’s parents’ house, wearing pink clothes to invigorate himself before greeting them.
This was a crazy judgment. His common sense was paralyzed. The father-in-law looked at his son-in-law wearing pink and shuddered.
He said to his daughter, “I can’t go out together with Makoto wearing such clothes.”
The daughter, sighing, made her husband in pink change his clothes. In fact, the daughter was already paralyzed, too.

Mr. Ikeda told me to write about him and MomoClo (Momoiro Clover Z) from early on.
Although I was once steamrollered into writing it, I was worried about the reaction of my acquaintances and I was not able to step forward to post the Monogatari of Mr. Ikeda’s photo collection of MomoClo readily.
At the very time when I was hesitating, I heard the news that Momoka Ariyasu, a member of MomoClo, would leave this group.
It was said that she would retire from the company and leave the entertainment world, saying “I want to become a normal girl”.
I didn’t even image that Momoka, who had great talent, would ever disappear. During the Momo-Clo concerts I went with Mr. Ikeda, I always cheered for her.
The sense of loss is big, and the attitude of the members who are left behind and try hard to look forward touches my heart.

Unexpectedly, the objective this time became to look back on MomoClo’s history and wish them good luck.

I must devote myself into this beyond all sense of shame.

Though I don’t want to call Mr. Ikeda a complete fool, I can’t deny that he is a little foolish. I will present you with his Aarin photo collection this time.

15 installments

Makoto Ikeda / photo ( Momoiro Clover Z ) (1)

Momo-Clo is a female idol group formed in 2008.
They made their major debut in 2010.
At first, the group was called “Momoiro Clover”, but changed their name to Momoiro Clover Z when Akari Hayami withdrew.

Since then, through their performance on Ko-haku Uta Gassen (Year-end Song Festival TV Program) on New Year’s Eve, their concert at National Stadium, and their 5 major dome tour, they have built up their position as a national idol group.
Their fans are diverse in age or gender, and many people come to their live concerts as a couple, which is a characteristic of Momo-Clo that is different to other idol groups.

At present (February 2018), the members are Kanako Momota (her image color is red), Shiori Tamai (yellow), Ayaka Sasaki (pink), and Reni Takagi (purple). Momoka Ariyasu (green) withdrew on January 21, 2018.

It was about 2011 when Mr. Ikeda first came to be obsessed with Momo-Clo. He is not that much of a very long-time fan.
TORIO, a shop specializing in idols, had three branches in Nakano Broadway in those days and had original photograph sections of girl’s idol groups.

Mr. Ikeda says.

“One day I saw that section on a whim, and I found some photos of the girls singing and dancing while sweating but with a smile, not posing for a shot. Well, I began to go to look at it whenever I went to Broadway. I was cheered up when I saw them.”

At the time Mr. Ikeda became aware of Momo-Clo for the first time.
Although each member wore their own image color, it was sometimes difficult for him to even distinguish them because their facial expressions were so different in each photo.

Mr. Ikeda went to that section for a year and a half and looked at the photos earnestly. Before long, he came to be able to tell the difference between them, whatever expressions they had. And then he became a fan of Ayaka Sasaki (Aarin) in pink. He began to buy the photographs little by little.


“There was a photo with an autograph in a showcase. It was sold for around 1000 yen in those days.”
Mr. Ikeda says, strongly impressed.
“How cheap! I thought.”
“Well, I suppose so.”
I said glumly.
“However, after all, you enter with paper articles, don’t you?”

Originally, Mr. Ikeda was a collector of old magazines including “Bouken-oh”.
He also devoted himself to Kamen-Rider-cards. By nature, he just can’t seem to resist paper articles that have serial numbers.
To enter the genre of idols through the photographs, and not through songs nor images, is incredibly consistent and retains his self-position, I think. Besides, unfortunately, it was the time when he had reached a certain point of collection of magazines and cards. His experience and enthusiasm seemed to have concentrated on photos.
“Well, very terrible from the start.”
I told him my honest impression.



(Bouken-oh)

By the way, Mr. Ikeda who became entranced by the photographs began to buy DVDs and began to go to their concerts.
He is not a great senior as a fan, and there may be some mistakes. But I’m going to write down information as far as Mr. Ikeda knows and cheer them on. Please forgive me if there are some unsatisfactory points.

Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z) (2)

Now, following Mr. Ikeda’s lecture, I will look back on the history of Momo-Clo’s photographs.

2008 – 2010: the days of Momoiro-Clover

Events were fans make direct contact with members such as autograph sessions, handshake sessions, and breakfast meetings etc., was carried out actively.
In addition, member participation and withdrawal were frequent.
The photographs of those days basically didn’t have a serial number. However there were some special photos from the “Side-story series”, “Kamon(the family crest) series”, presents in lucky drawings, and as supplements of a magazine. There are bromides with an autograph and a comment given out at events as well.

2011 – Momoiro-Clover-Z

Akari Hayami withdrew, and the group changed its name to “Momoiro Clover Z”.
Events that made contact like handshake sessions were abolished.
The photographs were sold at the goods counter at a live concert or through mail order. Usually one set of five pieces sold for 1, 000 yen. Sometimes it has an autograph, even a comment. But the probability decreased drastically.

Makoto Ikeda / photo ( Momoiro Clover Z )(3)

“unmarked photo”

The “unmarked photo” has neither a serial number nor a mark.
After “Momoiro-Clover” became “Momoiro-Clover-Z”, every official photograph basically has a serial number. So, an “unmarked photo” is one from the days of” Momoiro-Clover”.
But, the “Side-story series”, and the “Kamon (family crest) series” have numbers before Z. (described later)

In 2008 (the zero-generation members)
Only photographs. There was no activity like live concerts.
Reni Takagi, Miyu Wakura, Aimi Ikura, Tsukina Takai, Runa Yumikawa
March 2008, change in members.

May 17th (Group formed)
Reni Takagi, Miyu Wakura, Aimi Ikura, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Tsukina Takai.
(Yumikawa withdrew. Momota, Tamai participate.)

August 9, 2008
Reni Takagi, Miyu Wakura, Aimi Ikura, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Sumire Hujishiro.
(Takai withdrew, Fujishiro participates.)

November 23, 2008
Reni Takagi, Miyu Wakura, Aimi Ikura, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Sumire Fujishiro, Yukina Kashiwa, Akari Hayami, Ayaka Sasaki
(Kashiwa, Hayami, Sasaki participate)



Makoto Ikeda / photo ( Momoiro Clover Z ) (4)

The side-story series

Each photo has the words “side-story” and a heart mark, as well as the date and the serial number.
December 29, 2008
Reni Takagi, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Yukina Kashiwa, Akari Hayami, Ayaka Sasaki.
(Wakawa, Ikura withdrew)
As a special privilege for purchasers of the album, the 0th photo with autographs of all the members was offered. The album itself included an autograph too.

March 9, 2009
Reni Takagi, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Akari Hayami, Ayaka Sasaki
(Kashiwa withdrew. Afterwards, participation in Nogizaka 46)


Mr. Ikeda says.

“As I am not a senior fan I cannot know the whole picture, but it is only to the 99th at the most, I guess. Because I have not seen a three-digit serial number.”

The photos of this series are often autographed.

I sometimes saw one without an autograph in an idol shop until about 2013, but I scarcely see one now,” he added.

“By the way, I have seen a lot of “side-story” ones with an autograph at “Wink” in Mandarake. TORIO in Akihabara has them, too. I sometimes see them on the Internet auction sites too.”

He seems to search around frequently.

“Do you sell these photos?” I asked.

“I won’t! It’s different to when I’m making an exchange, but I won’t sell anything which has come into my possession.”

Mr. Ikeda said decidedly.

Makoto Ikeda /photo ( Momoiro Clover Z ) (5)

July 26, 2009

Reni Takagi, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Akari Hayami, Ayaka Sasaki, Momoka Ariyasu
(Ariyasu participes)

By the way, this is the time that Momo-Clo held their legendary Yamada Denki tour, and sold the CD of their indies debut “Momoiro Punch” by hand.

The “Kamon series” (numbered version)

About 2010
There are many photos which look nice, but there are none with a handwritten autograph that have been confirmed.



April 10, 2011
Reni Takagi, Kanako Momota, Shiori Tamai, Ayaka Sasaki, Momoka Ariyasu
(Hayami withdrew)

Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z)(7)

By the way, around 2012, the concert venue of Momo-Clo suddenly became larger and the audience increased. And with this, the autograph rate decreased.
In 2012, it was said that the manager tweeted “an autograph appears at the rate of 1 piece in 25 sets.”

According to Mr. Ikeda, he finds that it’s at the ratio of 1 per 20-30 sets in the summer of 2013. In the winter of 2013, it became around 1 per 50 sets, and this continues to the present.
Mr. Ikeda says,
“Usually, when people buy 10 sets, the probability of an autograph is 1/5. But, in fact, even if each buys a 10 set five times, one in every three or four people can’t win an autograph. Four to the power of five / five to the power of five = 1024/3125 is a blank. In addition, when they buy a 10 set ten times, one in every nine person can’t draw an autograph. It’s four to the power of ten / five to the power of ten.”
Mr. Ikeda, being very arithmetic, calculated.

I asked him his record until now.
When he was lucky, he once won one autograph from buying only 3 sets. Three times, he won one in 10 sets. But unfortunately, he drew nothing in 50 sets two times. In addition, nothing in 100 sets once, he said.
“100sets?!”
I unintentionally clenched my fist and hit Mr. Ikeda.
“I submit contentedly. Please.”
Obediently he lowered his head and I took this chance and hit him again.

Mr. Ikeda muttered in a low voice.
“Generally, when a seller sells it by the bundle of photos in one time, an autograph appears at the average rate. But when he/she sells each set separately, the rate of blanks increases. If we buy it by a mail order, the rate is close to the average. But I want to buy it at the merchandise counter of the venue.”
“Why?”
“The emotional uplift is excellent!” He said with sparkling eyes.
“Their own handwriting! Written by herself! Just after it, the live performance starts! The festive mood rises to its peak! ”
Mr. Ikeda carelessly forgot about his situation, and he returned to his eager tone all too quickly.

Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z )(8)

“Ore-no-Fujii” Series

“Ore-no-Fujii” is the event at which all the girl’s idol groups of Stardust co. gather together in the beginning of the year.
Momo-Clo participated in this until 2016 (as of 2018).

The official photographs exclusive to this event were sold in 2014 and 2015.
In 2014, they were snapshots where the members of various teams were mixed.
The event in 2015 was called “The seven days battle between Fujii and his wife” and continued for 7 days. On the 6th day, “My Top Ten” which was to decide the top ten among all the units and solos among the groups was held and special photographs were sold.
Solo shots for Momo-Clo (2 kinds each for the five members), Shiritu-Ebisu-Chugaku (2 each for the eight members), Team Shachihoko (2 each for the six members), Takoyaki Rainbow (3 each for the five members) were sold, totaling 53 kinds.
Five pieces sold as one set.
The autograph appeared about one piece in five sets. It was a high rate, but people didn’t necessarily get the one they wanted.

“It was super hard to win a photo of Momo-Clo with an autograph. I think that they could only “loop” up to around five times even if they lined up at the head of the line.”
“What’s “Loop”,” I asked.
“It’s to line up over again. Because we can buy only up to five sets, we go to the end of the line and line up from the beginning.
By the way, I did Loop three times on that day, and win four pieces of autograph. But there was not a Momo-Clo’s autograph among them. Moreover, we could buy only three sets at most near the end.”
Mr. Ikeda deplored.
“Ah, if only I had taken you to the concert that day! If the two of us had lined up, I might have been able to win Momo-Clo’s autograph.”
What awful things he does say in this delirium?
“But that’s alright,” Mr. Ikeda said and opened a folder.
“This I traded, and this I was given by ○○kun. See! I have a lot of them.”
The “seven days battle” photos with Momo-Clo’s autograph were put neatly in the folder.
“Do you want to look at them?” Mr. Ikeda said, smiling.
“No, enough of it for today.”
“No, look!!!”
I left him crying for me to look at them, and hurried away.  

Makoto Ikeda / photo ( Momoiro Clover Z ) (9)

In 2015, Reni Takagi solo concert.
In 2016, solo concerts of each member became all-out.
Aarin held a solo concert called “AYAKANATION” at Yokohama-Arena in 2016 and at Ryogoku-Kokugikan in 2017.
Official photographs were sold in both days.
(There were official photograph sales at Momota and Tamai’s “Momotamai-Kon” Concert in 2016 as well.)

Mr.Ikeda says.
“There are other photos like supplements to a magazine, a present in a drawing, and those distributed at an event. with an autograph is till 2012.
An authentication sticker has come to be pasted on the back side of a photo with an autograph since around September 2011.”

Makoto Ikeda / photo ( Momoiro Clover Z ) (10)

On the back side of the official photos, some tiny lettering appears.
At first, it was said that photos came with an autograph when it had lettering in one line and none when it was in two lines.
In the first edition, they seemed to write autographs intentionally on photos with one-line lettering. But after reprinting, the opposite phenomenon sometimes appeared, and some people exploited that to make fakes.
Lately, all the lettering is in a single line and it is difficult to tell a genuine autograph from a fake one by its backside.


the front side

the back side
(one-line lettering, without autograph)

Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z)(11)

As is unavoidable for any kind of autograph, some people forge autographs of Momo-Clo and sell them.
The imitation reached a peak during 2013 – 2014, Mr. Ikeda said.
“I couldn’t distinguish them in those days and I bought whatever I could find on the Internet. It is hard to tell the difference of those images on the Internet, after all.”
He seemed to have paid a very high learning fee.
He said,
“I can considerably distinguish them now. I know the fake style of four or five. And as soon as I see it, I can tell that this is made by A group, or that is made by B group.”
“Ohhh.”
I wonder how many stupid bitter experiences he has had to reach this stage.
He said.
“In the past, I figured it was a fake the moment I saw the envelope. Believe it or not, the handwriting of the address on the envelope was the same as the autograph of the photo.”
“You were cheated into buying such a thing?”
“No, I was not cheated but I went to catch it in the face of danger to study for myself.”
Mr. Ikeda denies it with every effort, but his voice is feeble.

Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z )(12)

Mr. Ikeda, who had experienced many hardships concerning fakes, complained: “What’s more, Aarin’s autograph is very unstable.”
You can tell from Kanako and Shiorin’s autographs that they are trying to prevent a fake, but Aarin’s autograph differs greatly, Mr. Ikeda says.

“As for Aarin’s autograph, I think I grasp all her styles from every term. But there are pieces which almost want to make me call them fakes if I hadn’t won them myself.”

According to Mr. Ikeda, Aarin’s autograph clearly has “the hurried version” “the careful version” and “the normal version”. In particularly, photos for her solo concert” AYAKANATION” are full of hastily written autographs because she had to write so many herself.
“If I drew a carefully written version at such a time, I would be rather uneasy.”
Mr. Ikeda with lost-looking eyes took out another piece.
“And then, there are ones were the form is too strange. See! This one! If this weren’t one I won myself, I would think it were a false.”
“Well, I can’t distinguish between them at all.”


Makoto Ikeda / photo(Momoiro Clover Z)(13)

An autograph is called strange when there is a difference between its form and the general style of the time it was written.
Mr. Ikeda says that he can distinguish Aarin’s autograph from each period.
“The other members scarcely change their form of autographs.
During , Shiorin temporarily altered hers to write from top to bottom, which is about the only thing. And then, as they grow, their autographs became more practiced and graceful. But Aarin’s autographs are unstable.”

The autograph’s rabbit and its ear sometimes grow thinner and sometimes fatter.
I had better refrain from writing detailed information not to give hints to counterfeiters.
While Mr. Ikeda made an impassioned speech about Aarin’s autograph, I looked through his album randomly.
“Oh, Aarin in this photograph, her face is strangely thin. Is this a fake?”
” I cannot understand what you say at all!”

Makoto Ikeda / photo (Momoiro Clover Z)(14)

Mr. Ikeda says there are some photos he especially cherishes.
They are the photos distributed in 2010 when Momo-Clo members came to the HMV music shop to hand them out.
On July 1, Ayaka Sasaki came. On July 4, Reni Takagi came. The other members also came to the store in sequence and distributed 50 photos each. The photos are ones especially for this event, and all of them have an autograph, a handwritten number and a comment.

” I don’t know whether the member distributed them in person, because I didn’t go to the scene.”
While saying so, Mr. Ikeda took out two photographs.
“These are the 1st and the 50th of Aarin’s photos from that time.”

Momo-Clo made their major debut with “Ikuze! Kaito-shoujo” (Let’s go! Phantom thief girls”) on May 5 that year. From about that time on, events at which fans could directly interact with the members were not held anymore.

Mr. Ikeda says,
“These photographs from the HMV event are those of the last period when the members directly distributed their photos with autographs. The end of direct interaction events is also the period when they started climbing up the stairs to becoming a national idol group. These photos are both the end and the beginning. It shows Momo-Clo’s history in many layers, which is deeply impressive for me.”

Makoto Ikeda / photo( Momoiro Clover Z )(15)

After Momoka’s announcement of withdrawal, Mr. Ikeda worried all the time.
At first, he was shocked by her withdrawal; next, he was shocked by not being able to win a ticket to Momoka’s last concert. And then, he took slight consolation in getting a ticket to the live viewing event.
On January 21st, 2018, Mr. Ikeda and I saw the last live concert at the live viewing hall neighboring the concert hall.

After the concert ended, Mr. Ikeda said.
“It’s all right. The clover, Momo-Clo’s mark, has four leaves after all.”
“I got tickets for two days of The Valentine event. I will go to the tenth anniversary event in Tokyo Dome too. I believe they will manage successfully…”
Mr. Ikeda wiped his tears and took off the green uniform which he wore saying “only today”. He ended up in just black trainers, but in fact, he was wearing a pink T-shirt underneath.

Finally, I should write down a little about myself who stands by Mr. Ikeda and his photo buying.
I don’t know why, but I became emotionally unable to watch TV after the earthquake disaster of 3.11 in 2011.I spent days moping, and it was the Ko-haku Singing Contest on the last day of 2012 that broke my long refraining of TV. At that time, I saw Momo-Clo for the first time. I thought that we still have a future if there are girls like this.
“To make people smile”・・・Momo-Clo is head and shoulders above the others in their sense of resolution and sense of mission.
How heavy it is for the girls to take on this determination as an idol.
I thought that their group of five was permanent, but I was mistaken. A live concert is always only once in itself.
There will be various changes. But the memory they have lit up will be left clearly. I think it is lucky to be able to create more of these memories in the future too.
I was lucky to have come across them in this period. If we meet it, we can’t mistake it for something else. We can clearly identify what is genuine…like a diamond in the midst of ashes.


Fin.